Personally, I do everything that I can to avoid the use of AI; for example, on search engines, I try to remember to use the "-ai" tag so that the search engine does not generate an AI summary. I am a clinical faculty member at one of B.C.'s universities, and we have AI guidelines with relation to courses, instructor use, and student use.
I want to encourage the staff at schools to be wary of AI-generated materials for the classroom, as AI has been known to have "hallucinations" and generate all sorts of fake citations and sources. In addition, AI-generated images, like maps, are known to have glaring errors.
I want to consult with residents and staff about a District-wide policy on AI so that we minimize AI use as much as possible and encourage learning from a vast number of resources opposed to only AI summaries. This will facilitate the development of critical thinking skills in our students.
There is also the concern about the environmental impact of AI and AI data centres. As a Victoria resident I am mindful about this impact on our beautiful environment and the Island we call home.
SOGI stands for sexual orientation and gender identity. Everyone has a sexual orientation and a gender identity, and schools should be inclusive and safe spaces that do not discriminate on the basis of these two personal attributes.
I stand with the 2SLGBTQIA+ (Two-Spirit, Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer, Intersex, Asexual and more) community against homophobia, biphobia, transphobia, and other forms of hate and discrimination.
SOGI 123 is not a curriculum. SOGI 123 is a set of age-appropriate resources that teachers and parents/guardians can draw upon to discuss SOGI, to allow for safer and more inclusive schools. As a speech-language pathologist, I value these resources as they provide the language that describes people's diverse experiences and identities. SOGI 123 is also an anti-bullying resource, as fostering inclusivity promotes better understanding of people's similarities and differences. Please see the Greater Victoria School District's webpage on SOGI 123 here and you can learn more from the official SOGI 123 website.
The Greater Victoria School District has been participating in the Victoria Pride Parade for a number of years now, and I encourage this participation for years to come.
It is impossible to tease out the topic of SPLOs from the firing and eventual reinstatement of the current SD61 Board of Education. In addition, there are senior employees of the School District who are on leave, possibly in relation to this issue. My hope is that the school system can still operate at this time in the absence of these senior officials.
For me as a former SD61 employee, I was a bit confused as to the role of the liaison officer when I worked in the schools. I am going to quote one of my former SLP colleagues in SD61, who authored an article linked here:
"Before I retired from my role as an itinerant speech-language pathologist in SD 61, I found it difficult to understand the role of the SPLO. The transparency regarding their schedules and duties was lacking. If I wasn’t clear about why a police officer was standing in the office or walking in the halls, I can only imagine how unclear the students might have been. This lack of clarity raises important questions about whether the program could be contributing to profiling. It feels strange to have a police presence in a public institution without a specific, stated requirement for their involvement."
I will also share my own experience. I grew up in a "poor" neighbourhood in Toronto, in housing run by the municipal housing corporation (public housing or social housing). Police would regularly raid nearby residences for various reasons. I learned at a young age to avoid the police, as getting questioned by police, detained by police, or a mistaken identity would destroy opportunities. I am a racialized person of primarily Southeast Asian descent, and with regard to my Vietnamese-Canadian community, there were unfortunate stereotypes about us regarding cannabis growing and dealing back when cannabis was still illegal. I am not an Indigenous person nor a Black person, and I do not speak for them, but there have been data that show that Indigenous people and Black people have a disproportionately high number of police interactions. We need to make sure that any police interactions on school property uphold the human rights of students and staff.
That being said, I recognize that people of a wide variety of backgrounds, including Indigenous and Black persons, have had positive experiences with police, and schools require the presence of first responders (police, fire, ambulance), namely in times of emergencies. I have heard from some members of the community that there is also a desire for staff and students to interact with first responders on a basis where they are not responding to emergencies. We know that police services play a role outside emergencies: for example, in relation to schools specifically, we need our police to ensure road safety in our school zones, as motorists in motor vehicles should be ticketed when speeding above 30 km/h. I recognize that there are also considerations as to whether police officers, school staff, and/or others should provide information in relation to bicycle safety, pedestrian safety, personal safety, knowledge of the law, and so on.
I recognize that the discussion around SPLOs is very divisive: I refer you, the reader, to articles that show local residents who are against SPLOs and residents and groups who are referenced as being for SPLOs, namely three SD61 municipalities, the Songhees Nation, the Xʷsepsəm/Esquimalt Nation, and the Victoria Police Department (VicPD).
The current SD61 Board of Education was fired because they reportedly did not follow, from the Minister of Education and Child Care, Ministerial Order M339/2024 and then Ministerial Order M406/2024. There was also concern from Indigenous groups about adequate transparency and collaboration on part of the Board. That being said, what has come to light in news articles is that there were inappropriate communications in the form of text messages between the Associate Deputy Education Minister and the independently appointed special advisor, as well as between the Associate Deputy Education Minister and the Deputy Chief of VicPD. This revelation led to the Province reinstating the current Board of Education in May of this year.
Boards of Education in B.C. follow the School Act and police services in B.C. follow the Police Act. Boards of Education and police services are creations of the Province and thus both follow the direction of the provincial government of the day. Regardless of how the current Board of Education was initially dismissed, the provincial government has essentially made SPLOs mandatory. As a School Trustee candidate and a member of the community, what I don't want to do is to give a provincial government any reason to fire an elected board; to me, there is a form of damage done to the community with having one appointed Official Trustee do work of an elected Board: for example, budgets can be passed with minimal discussion as to the cuts and effects caused. In addition, for the sake of our students and staff, who deserve a safe place to learn and work, and for any visitors in our schools, an elected Board of Education should be there at the table to consult with all parties and clarify and set standards and policies for SPLOs. The Vancouver School Board and the Vancouver Police Department, for example, have set training and appearance standards for their SPLOs: "less formal uniforms, cultural awareness training and smaller, less exposed firearms". Not that this is happening, but we don't expect the liaison offers in schools to be dressed like the SWAT team; schools are places of learning for students and a workplace for staff. The VSB and VPD also had a third party evaluate their liaison officer program and I am hoping that SD61 and the four police services would be amenable to this type of third-party evaluation to provide information to all parties, including the provincial government, moving forward in a constructive way.
I do not want to spend public monies on lawyers rehashing battles between a previous Board and a previous government; this should not come at a cost to services and education for our students.
In summary,
I personally felt discomfort from police presence as a child. However, this personal anecdotal experience does not discount the role of police in terms of school safety, like enforcement of traffic speeds in school zones and for emergencies. I recognize all perspectives and I want to work for all students and staff to make schools safe.
Police are not barred from schools; it is not in the power of a School District or Board of Education to bar police from schools, as police are called upon for things like 9-1-1 calls.
For the SPLO program in SD61, I want there to be an elected Board at the table to represent the community with regard to review and set out parameters of the program, including what information is gathered, what outcomes are measured, and roles. For me, cultural safety training, appropriate uniforms, and less exposed firearms are a small ask, as that has been executed in Vancouver with the VSB and VPD. I also would like some consistency across the four police services, as our Greater Victoria School District spans multiple municipalities, reserves, and police departments, in contrast to some other School Districts that are coterminous with a single municipality and its police department.
In regards to reviewing the safety plan, it is imperative that the SD61 Board of Education consult with:
The Four Houses, including the Songhees Nation and the Xʷsepsəm/Esquimalt Nation
VicPD, the Saanich Police Department, the Oak Bay Police Department, and West Shore RCMP
School and district staff
Students and parents/guardians
Safety experts
Other relevant parties, including the provincial government and the community
We need to make sure that any police interactions in our schools uphold the human rights of students and staff, and do not disrupt the safe and inclusive learning environment provided in our schools.
I am a big proponent of proportional representation in general, not just in the voting-systems sense of the term, so I understand and also have concerns about the how the number or residents represented by each trustee differs. I do support increased Indigenous representation on the Board and so the two Nations (Songhees Nation and Xʷsepsəm/Esquimalt Nation) having one trustee each is important in terms of working together as a community and furthering Reconciliation.
With regard to the possibility of increasing the number of trustees to provide balance in representation by population, from my understanding of the School Act, a Board of Education can only have 5, 7, or 9 trustees, so increasing the board size is impossible unless the Act is amended, since the SD61 Board is already at 9 trustees.
In terms of reviewing the ward system, as a School Trustee I would review whether the Board could suggest to the provincial government a modification of the boundaries of the Trustee Electoral Areas to have some population balance, while trying to respect School District commitments to Reconciliation with the two Nations in SD61. I would note that the whole ward process was initiated by the elected municipal council of the Township of Esquimalt, and so, even though municipal boundaries are rather arbitrary, there is a demand for balanced geographic representation of the SD61 Board, which this 7 TEA system is supposed to represent.
Perhaps a move to a few zones, like in SD62 with the two zones of the Belmont Zone and the Milnes Landing Zone, could work. This would require further consultation with the two Nations, the municipalities, the Ministry of Education and Child Care, and the general public.